When reading
Max Weber’s “The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism” it’s easy to
see how much emphasis he puts on culture as being directly correlated to the amount
of economic success seen in a particular state/region of the world. He makes it
clear that he believes the “West” has it right when it comes to just about
everything from art to architecture to math to economics. One could argue that
he’s a little biased in his treatment of the “East,” but he does bring up some
interesting questions regarding the importance of culture on the success of a
state’s economic system. I’d like to discuss whether or not culture will have
as pronounced of an effect on a state’s economic system 250 years from now as Weber
believed it did in 1920.
I argue that
a state’s culture will have an increasingly minimal effect on a state’s economy
going into the future. The world is becoming much more global and we have the
technology and transportation infrastructures in place which allow us to be in
any country in the world within hours if need be. More people are traveling and
living abroad than were back in 1920, and that trend won’t stop. The more people
are exposed to other cultures, the more they incorporate some of the “foreign”
customs they’ve picked up into their own lives. Looking forward 250 years from
now, more of the world may look a bit like New York City or London in terms of being a
giant “melting pot” of cultures. I fully expect that national/regional cultures
will still exist, but they may just not have as much as a profound impact as Weber
believed they did in 1920.
Dave, you raise a good point. One I have thought about myself. I agree that the world is becoming much more integrated, but I'm not sure that 250 years is necessarily enough time for some cultural barriers to be broken in the East, particularly those most dominant in the muslim extremist groups. In many parts of the world there is still a population of people who are very against "western culture." I can see that the integrations of the world itself is speeding up, so who knows. Maybe in 250 years there will be much more acceptance of other cultures.
ReplyDeleteInteresting idea. What do you mean by a state's culture? Is a consequence of a proposed decline in the significance of states?
ReplyDelete